{
 "paper": "gadeke-2026-guilt-insula",
 "adjudicated": "2026-09-12",
 "by": "supplied:runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.v4.json",
 "note": "Verdicts for spans the mechanical match could not resolve. covered = a claim does account for it; gap = a real hole; not-an-assertion = the span states no result of its own. Every verdict carries `sha`, the fingerprint of the sentence it judged. A `gap` also carries `tree`, the fingerprint of which claims existed when it was judged, and a `covered` carries `claim_sha`, the wording of the claim it named — because a gap is a statement about the tree, and closing one is exactly the edit that used to leave the verdict standing over nothing. `coverage` discards a verdict whose fingerprints no longer match rather than applying a judgement nobody made about what is there now.",
 "spans": [
  {
   "uid": "introduction-032",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Narrates the paradigm — three conditions with a partner — rather than stating a result; a component of the paper's scope.",
   "sha": "6f712c35"
  },
  {
   "uid": "introduction-038",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A figure title, not a finding.",
   "sha": "b562d627"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-068",
   "verdict": "covered",
   "claim": "parameter-recovery-procedure-synthetic-data-generated",
   "why": "The parameter-recovery claim states exactly this verification of the fitted happiness-model parameters.",
   "sha": "f540af1f",
   "claim_sha": "2c3d9424"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-075",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Analysis narration introducing the guilt LMM; the effects it foreshadows are stated as their own claims below.",
   "sha": "f0f52e59"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-097",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A pointer to Appendix 1—table 4 that the coefficients differ from zero, not a result stated here.",
   "sha": "432db563"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-100",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A pointer to Appendix 1—table 6 that the coefficients differ from zero, not a result stated here.",
   "sha": "63d30cde"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-111",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Narration of how the region-wise models were applied, with data not shown; asserts no result.",
   "sha": "42326f25"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-114",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Narration of model selection with and without the Run factor, pointing to two appendix tables.",
   "sha": "2e2946f5"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-123",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Narration that all factors and interactions were significant (data not shown), then how the per-region models were fitted.",
   "sha": "468b36ed"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-143",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A left-IFG cluster with the insula seed showed the same connectivity effect but did not survive correction; no claim records this sub-threshold cluster.",
   "sha": "fc08dc26",
   "tree": "77dc607a"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-144",
   "verdict": "covered",
   "claim": "left-ifg-cluster-showed-opposite",
   "why": "The claim states this STS-seed left-IFG cluster with the opposite (Safe-self/Risky-both) pattern that did not survive correction.",
   "sha": "b8af3b47",
   "claim_sha": "88a2ee04"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-147",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A figure-supplement title naming what is plotted rather than stating a finding.",
   "sha": "5bf8ef0a"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-148",
   "verdict": "covered",
   "claim": "left-ifg-cluster-showed-opposite",
   "why": "Restates the STS-seed left-IFG opposite-pattern connectivity that the claim records as not surviving correction.",
   "sha": "50a6749a",
   "claim_sha": "88a2ee04"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-001",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A figure title.",
   "sha": "b5ebcada"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-033",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A pointer to Appendix 1—table 4 rather than a result stated in the caption.",
   "sha": "432db563"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-036",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A pointer to Appendix 1—table 6 rather than a result stated in the caption.",
   "sha": "63d30cde"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-045",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Explains what dots, markers and error bars encode; a graphical-encoding note, not a finding.",
   "sha": "3985fd4e"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-046",
   "verdict": "covered",
   "claim": "left-ifg-cluster-showed-opposite",
   "why": "The STS-seed to left-IFG connectivity with the opposite pattern that did not survive correction is exactly what the claim records.",
   "sha": "50a6749a",
   "claim_sha": "88a2ee04"
  },
  {
   "uid": "tables-002",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Raw model-fit rows (R2, BIC, AIC) and a software list; the model comparison they support is stated as its own claims.",
   "sha": "54cdd22e"
  },
  {
   "uid": "tables-008",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Raw cluster coordinates for the Risky>safe and Social>Solo decision-phase contrasts the tree already carries.",
   "sha": "241ffdf7"
  },
  {
   "uid": "tables-016",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "This LMM row is the only place the decision-phase Risky−Safe Social-versus-Solo coefficients per ROI are reported; no claim carries them beyond precuneus/TPJ.",
   "sha": "a4884d7f",
   "tree": "77dc607a"
  },
  {
   "uid": "tables-019",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "This LMM row is the only place the decision-phase Risky−Safe Social-versus-Partner coefficients per ROI are reported; no claim carries them beyond precuneus/TPJ.",
   "sha": "70a1fe46",
   "tree": "77dc607a"
  },
  {
   "uid": "tables-022",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Raw cluster coordinates for the risky-versus-safe outcome-phase contrast the tree already carries.",
   "sha": "f300c978"
  },
  {
   "uid": "tables-031",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Alongside the claimed insula effect, this row is the only place the right middle-temporal response to low partner outcomes (Social>Partner) is reported.",
   "sha": "76a9fec8",
   "tree": "77dc607a"
  },
  {
   "uid": "tables-032",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "This row is the only place the right middle-temporal low-minus-high outcome difference (Social>Partner) is reported; no claim carries it.",
   "sha": "2060caf1",
   "tree": "77dc607a"
  }
 ]
}