{
 "paper": "kammer-2026-foveal-feedback",
 "adjudicated": "2026-09-11",
 "by": "supplied:runs/kammer-2026-foveal-feedback/adjudication.answer.json",
 "note": "Verdicts for spans the mechanical match could not resolve. covered = a claim does account for it; gap = a real hole; not-an-assertion = the span states no result of its own. Every verdict carries `sha`, the fingerprint of the sentence it judged. A `gap` also carries `tree`, the fingerprint of which claims existed when it was judged, and a `covered` carries `claim_sha`, the wording of the claim it named — because a gap is a statement about the tree, and closing one is exactly the edit that used to leave the verdict standing over nothing. `coverage` discards a verdict whose fingerprints no longer match rather than applying a judgement nobody made about what is there now.",
 "spans": [
  {
   "uid": "results-003",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Design narration: it says why a block design was chosen and reports no result of its own.",
   "sha": "000804db"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-013",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A bare panel label telling the reader what the illustration depicts, not a finding.",
   "sha": "fa264e27"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-017",
   "verdict": "covered",
   "claim": "foveal-v1-decodes-peripheral-saccade-target",
   "why": "The claim already specifies the four saccade targets as varying in shape and semantic category, which is exactly the stimulus set this panel depicts.",
   "sha": "40f7e118",
   "claim_sha": "f6f5df80"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-021",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Narration of how the control condition was run; it states no outcome of its own.",
   "sha": "e270d3ab"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-023",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Narration of why four natural stimuli were used, asserting nothing about what was found.",
   "sha": "9d0ac6e9"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-044",
   "verdict": "covered",
   "claim": "decoding-shape-sensitive-not-semantic",
   "why": "The section heading states the shape-sensitive, category-insensitive result that this claim makes.",
   "sha": "a2ece563",
   "claim_sha": "72a4f6df"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-048",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A schematic panel label explaining which comparisons are drawn, not a result.",
   "sha": "ed2ba163"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-055",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A bare supplementary-figure title with no finding attached.",
   "sha": "b074ff40"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-070",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Narration of ROI selection with supporting citations; the analysis result comes in the sentences that follow.",
   "sha": "6388dea3"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-077",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "No claim carries this null: the tree states the IPS foveal effect and the FEF/LO non-significance, but never that peripheral decoding was unrelated to activity in any ROI.",
   "sha": "5c4df3c3",
   "tree": "f5b9ef57"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-078",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "The tree has no claim ruling out global brain fluctuations or signal-to-noise as explanations of the parametric modulation effects.",
   "sha": "424097a9",
   "tree": "f5b9ef57"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-080",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A bare panel label naming the cortical masks shown.",
   "sha": "e75150e3"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-084",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A bare supplementary-figure title with no finding attached.",
   "sha": "ac30bd88"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-085",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Analysis narration stating which analysis was repeated, with no result.",
   "sha": "47105b02"
  },
  {
   "uid": "results-088",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "The control-condition null for peripheral decoding across FEF, IPS and LO is reported nowhere in the claim tree.",
   "sha": "dc5e84b3",
   "tree": "f5b9ef57"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-020",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A panel label naming the quantity plotted and the sample size, without stating any outcome.",
   "sha": "ffbe1de5"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-023",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A bare supplementary-figure title with no finding attached.",
   "sha": "5aadb48b"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-029",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A panel label naming which analysis is displayed, without stating its outcome.",
   "sha": "aabc87eb"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-031",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "A bare supplementary-figure title with no finding attached.",
   "sha": "98635326"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-032",
   "verdict": "not-an-assertion",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "Analysis narration stating which analysis was repeated, with no result.",
   "sha": "47105b02"
  },
  {
   "uid": "captions-035",
   "verdict": "gap",
   "claim": null,
   "why": "This caption is one of the only places the control-condition peripheral-decoding null across all three ROIs is reported, and no claim states it.",
   "sha": "dc5e84b3",
   "tree": "f5b9ef57"
  }
 ]
}