{
  "paper": "gadeke-2026-guilt-insula",
  "layer": {
    "id": "external-review",
    "title": "External review",
    "question": "What structure did the three readers systematically miss?",
    "kind": "step",
    "group": "induction",
    "needs": [
      "reconcile"
    ],
    "views": [
      "table",
      "comparison"
    ]
  },
  "version": 3,
  "versions": [
    {
      "v": 3,
      "ran": "2026-09-12T09:00:01Z",
      "note": "external-review under the current chain (#96)",
      "by": "Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) (subagent, via --answer)",
      "kind": "step",
      "cmd": "cd extract && python3 -m elife_extract.cli external-review --paper gadeke-2026-guilt-insula --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/external-review.answer.v3.json",
      "layer": "external-review"
    },
    {
      "v": 2,
      "ran": "2026-09-11T19:15:06Z",
      "note": "first run under the prompt contract (#56 item 4); Opus 5 subagents for every layer; answered through --dump-prompt/--answer, not the configured backend",
      "by": "claude-opus-5 (subagent, via --answer)",
      "kind": "step",
      "cmd": "cd extract && python3 -m elife_extract.cli external-review --paper gadeke-2026-guilt-insula --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/external-review.answer.v2.json",
      "layer": "external-review"
    },
    {
      "v": 1,
      "ran": "2026-09-11T19:14:23Z",
      "note": "first run under the prompt contract (#56 item 4); Sonnet 5 subagents read, Opus 5 subagents reconciled, reviewed and inferred edges; answered through --dump-prompt/--answer, not the configured backend",
      "by": "claude-opus-5 (subagent, via --answer)",
      "kind": "step",
      "cmd": "cd extract && python3 -m elife_extract.cli external-review --paper gadeke-2026-guilt-insula --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/external-review.answer.v1.json",
      "layer": "external-review"
    }
  ],
  "state": "stale",
  "ran": "2026-09-12T09:00:01Z",
  "by": "Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) (subagent, via --answer)",
  "note": "external-review under the current chain (#96)",
  "moved": null,
  "lost": null,
  "blocked_by": null,
  "unrecorded_upstream": null,
  "produces": [
    "runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/external-review.output.json",
    "runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/external-review.patch.json"
  ],
  "command": "cd extract && python3 -m claim_graphs.cli external-review --paper gadeke-2026-guilt-insula",
  "href": "/elife-claim-trees/papers/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/external-review/"
}