Verification check

blocked upstream · v3 provisional awaiting approval

Does a re-run stand behind each claim, read beside its warrant?

for Contributions of insula and superior temporal sulcus to interpersonal guilt and responsibility in social decisions · this layer across all papers · json

Provisional

This layer needs a corpus-scope decision that has not been ruled on yet, so what it produces would change if the decision changed. It waits on claim-format, relation-vocab.

Awaiting approval

Waiting for approval. That is a statement about the record, not about whether anyone has read this: people read the corpus without stamping what they read, and only a stamp leaves a trace. Approval is an operation on a version, not a step of its own — it is recorded against the version it was granted to, so running this layer again does not carry it forward.

What it produced68 checks

Read from runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/verification-check.output.json · 11 KB.

#	slug	check_verification	check_verification_from
1	alt-agency-aversion-not-guilt	unrecorded	`[]`
2	alt-guilt-effect-driven-by-own-outcome	unrecorded	`[]`
3	alt-imaging-contrast-invalid	unrecorded	`[]`
4	alt-model-based-glm-invalid	unrecorded	`[]`
5	alt-participants-insensitive-to-value	unrecorded	`[]`
6	alt-social-context-shifts-risk-attitude	unrecorded	`[]`
7	among-computational-models-fitted-momentary	unrecorded	`[]`
8	anterior-insula-neural-substrate-guilt	unrecorded	`[]`
9	anterior-insula-tracks-guilt-insula	unrecorded	`[]`
10	authors-suggest-left-sts-region	unrecorded	`[]`
11	behavioural-guilt-effect-larger-happiness	unrecorded	`[]`
12	bilateral-ventral-striatum-more-active	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:blocked","provenance:PASS measured"]`
13	both-studies-participants-felt-worse	unrecorded	`[]`
14	connectivity-between-guilt-responsibility-related-outcome-ph	unrecorded	`[]`
15	connectivity-between-left-anterior-insula	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:blocked","provenance:PASS measured"]`
16	decisions-social-compared-solo-condition	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:blocked","provenance:PASS measured"]`
17	difference-response-between-low-high	unrecorded	`[]`
18	dot-products-between-individual-neural	reproduced	`["record:partial","record:verified","provenance:PASS measured"]`
19	during-outcome-phase-responses-low	unrecorded	`[]`
20	during-receipt-lottery-versus-safe	unrecorded	`[]`
21	each-trial-participants-chose-between	unrecorded	`[]`
22	findings-rest-two-samples-healthy	blocked	`["record:blocked"]`
23	functional-connectivity-between-guilt-responsibility-related	unrecorded	`[]`
24	functional-connectivity-between-left-anterior	unrecorded	`[]`
25	guilt-effect-occurred-whether-participant	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:unattempted","provenance:PASS measured"]`
26	hold-partner-behaviour-constant-across	blocked	`["record:blocked"]`
27	individual-grbs-dot-product-values-not	reproduced	`["record:partial","record:unattempted","provenance:WARN measured"]`
28	insula-rois-responded-more-low	unrecorded	`[]`
29	left-ifg-cluster-showed-opposite	unrecorded	`[]`
30	left-superior-temporal-sulcus-cluster	unrecorded	`[]`
31	likelihood-ratio-test-showed-responsibility	unattempted	`["record:unattempted"]`
32	linear-mixed-model-containing-all	unrecorded	`[]`
33	lower-happiness-when-participant-decision-maker	unrecorded	`[]`
34	manipulation-check-bilateral-ventral-striatum	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:blocked","provenance:PASS measured"]`
35	mass-univariate-voxel-wise-analysis-found-small	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:verified","provenance:PASS measured"]`
36	mixed-effects-regressions-choices-social-condition	unrecorded	`[]`
37	model-based-glm-entered-best-fitting-computational	unrecorded	`[]`
38	model-selection-among-happiness-models	unrecorded	`[]`
39	momentary-happiness-modelled-five-computational	unrecorded	`[]`
40	neural-substrate-tracks-participant-responsibility-2	unrecorded	`[]`
41	neural-substrate-tracks-participant-responsibility	unrecorded	`[]`
42	no-significant-interaction-between-difference	unrecorded	`[]`
43	one-cluster-left-sts-responded	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:blocked","provenance:PASS measured"]`
44	only-precuneus-tpj-showed-positive	unrecorded	`[]`
45	parameter-recovery-procedure-synthetic-data-generated	unrecorded	`[]`
46	participant-happiness-lower-when-participant	reproduced	`["record:partial","record:unattempted","provenance:WARN measured"]`
47	participant-momentary-happiness-varied-rewards-2	partial	`["record:verified","record:verified"]`
48	participant-momentary-happiness-varied-rewards	unrecorded	`[]`
49	participants-chose-risky-option-lottery	reproduced	`["record:partial","record:unattempted","provenance:WARN measured"]`
50	participants-own-reward-prediction-errors	unrecorded	`[]`
51	participants-probability-choosing-risky-option	partial	`["record:partial","record:verified"]`
52	participants-showed-very-similar-risk	unrecorded	`[]`
53	participants-slightly-more-risk-averse	unrecorded	`[]`
54	partner-reward-prediction-errors-resulting	reproduced	`["record:verified","record:unattempted","provenance:PASS measured"]`
55	pre-task-icebreaker-succeeded-establishing-positive	unrecorded	`[]`
56	prior-functional-connectivity-work-shown	unrecorded	`[]`
57	prior-literature-documents-association-between	unrecorded	`[]`
58	responsibility-choices-not-influence-happiness	unrecorded	`[]`
59	responsibility-model-yielded-higher-values	unrecorded	`[]`
60	responsibility-outcomes-generates-guilt-participant	unrecorded	`[]`
61	responsibility-partner-outcomes-influences-participant	unrecorded	`[]`
62	responsibility-redux-model-incorporating-expected	unrecorded	`[]`
63	responsibility-social-choice-yields-low	unrecorded	`[]`
64	risk-aversion-parameter-not-differ-between	unrecorded	`[]`
65	risk-premiums-not-differ-between	unattempted	`["record:unattempted"]`
66	rutledge-colleagues-established-changes-momentary	unrecorded	`[]`
67	study-reproduced-study-design-inside	unrecorded	`[]`
68	when-partner-received-low-lottery	partial	`["record:verified","record:verified"]`

How it is defined

What this layer reads besides its dependencies. Each is a declared input: its content is hashed into every run, so editing one makes those runs stale.

extract/claim_graphs/verification_check.pythe script that runs itnot in the repository

The declaration names this path and the repository does not have it. An input that does not exist hashes to nothing, so it cannot make a run stale — the layer is declared to depend on something it is not in fact tracking.

Artifacts

runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/verification-check.output.json

Versions

From the run ledger. There is no changelog beside it to keep in step.

v3 · 2026-09-14 · scripts/pipeline.py run

ran via scripts/pipeline.py

cd extract && python3 -m claim_graphs.cli verification-check --paper gadeke-2026-guilt-insula
v2 · 2026-09-13 · scripts/pipeline.py run

re-run on tree v7 after edge completion + warrant v3

cd extract && python3 -m elife_extract.cli verification-check --paper gadeke-2026-guilt-insula
v1 · 2026-09-13 · scripts/pipeline.py run

ran via scripts/pipeline.py

cd extract && python3 -m elife_extract.cli verification-check --paper gadeke-2026-guilt-insula

This layer across the corpus

Across the corpus

8 not run · 1 stale · 1 blocked upstream·a paper links to its own cell, where this layer's output for it is rendered

Paper	State	Version	Last run	Output	Cell
A three-dimensional immunofluorescence atlas of the …	not run	—	—	—	json
Distinct representational properties of cues and con…	not run	—	—	—	json
Computational modelling identifies key determinants …ran via scripts/pipeline.py	stale	v1	2026-09-13	verification-check.output.json	json
Contributions of insula and superior temporal sulcus…ran via scripts/pipeline.py	blocked upstream	v3	2026-09-14	verification-check.output.json	json
Spatially targeted inhibitory rhythms differentially…	not run	—	—	—	json
Feedback of peripheral saccade targets to early fove…	not run	—	—	—	json
iGABASnFR2 is an improved genetically encoded protei…	not run	—	—	—	json
A deep learning pipeline for mapping in situ network…	not run	—	—	—	json
Self-association enhances early attentional selectio…	not run	—	—	—	json
Impaired excitability of fast-spiking neurons in a n…	not run	—	—	—	json

Inputs and outputs

Reads, besides its dependencies: extract/claim_graphs/verification_check.py · declared, and not in the repository — it hashes to nothing, so it cannot make a run stale
Produces: runs/{paper}/verification-check.output.json

One per paper — the table above links each one that exists.
Views: table — rendered above, over the 25 checks in the artifact

Running it

The command comes from the declaration, so this text and what actually runs cannot diverge. pipeline.py run also runs the unmet dependencies first.

python3 scripts/pipeline.py run <paper> verification-check

Underneath, that runs cd extract && python3 -m claim_graphs.cli verification-check --paper {paper}.