Coverage adjudication
stale · v4 provisional awaiting approvalOf the spans the matcher could not resolve, which are real gaps?
for Contributions of insula and superior temporal sulcus to interpersonal guilt and responsibility in social decisions · this layer across all papers · json
Provisional
This layer needs a corpus-scope decision that has not been ruled on yet, so what it produces would change if the decision changed. It waits on claim-format, relation-vocab.
Awaiting approval
Waiting for approval. That is a statement about the record, not about whether anyone has read this: people read the corpus without stamping what they read, and only a stamp leaves a trace. Approval is an operation on a version, not a step of its own — it is recorded against the version it was granted to, so running this layer again does not carry it forward.
What it produced25 spans
Read from mappings/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula.json · 7 KB. adjudicated 2026-09-12by supplied:runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.v4.json
| # | uid | verdict | claim | why | sha | claim_sha | tree |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | introduction-032 | not-an-assertion | — | Narrates the paradigm — three conditions with a partner — rather than stating a result; a component of the paper's scope. | 6f712c35 | — | — |
| 2 | introduction-038 | not-an-assertion | — | A figure title, not a finding. | b562d627 | — | — |
| 3 | results-068 | covered | parameter-recovery-procedure-synthetic-data-generated | The parameter-recovery claim states exactly this verification of the fitted happiness-model parameters. | f540af1f | 2c3d9424 | — |
| 4 | results-075 | not-an-assertion | — | Analysis narration introducing the guilt LMM; the effects it foreshadows are stated as their own claims below. | f0f52e59 | — | — |
| 5 | results-097 | not-an-assertion | — | A pointer to Appendix 1—table 4 that the coefficients differ from zero, not a result stated here. | 432db563 | — | — |
| 6 | results-100 | not-an-assertion | — | A pointer to Appendix 1—table 6 that the coefficients differ from zero, not a result stated here. | 63d30cde | — | — |
| 7 | results-111 | not-an-assertion | — | Narration of how the region-wise models were applied, with data not shown; asserts no result. | 42326f25 | — | — |
| 8 | results-114 | not-an-assertion | — | Narration of model selection with and without the Run factor, pointing to two appendix tables. | 2e2946f5 | — | — |
| 9 | results-123 | not-an-assertion | — | Narration that all factors and interactions were significant (data not shown), then how the per-region models were fitted. | 468b36ed | — | — |
| 10 | results-143 | gap | — | A left-IFG cluster with the insula seed showed the same connectivity effect but did not survive correction; no claim records this sub-threshold cluster. | fc08dc26 | — | 77dc607a |
| 11 | results-144 | covered | left-ifg-cluster-showed-opposite | The claim states this STS-seed left-IFG cluster with the opposite (Safe-self/Risky-both) pattern that did not survive correction. | b8af3b47 | 88a2ee04 | — |
| 12 | results-147 | not-an-assertion | — | A figure-supplement title naming what is plotted rather than stating a finding. | 5bf8ef0a | — | — |
| 13 | results-148 | covered | left-ifg-cluster-showed-opposite | Restates the STS-seed left-IFG opposite-pattern connectivity that the claim records as not surviving correction. | 50a6749a | 88a2ee04 | — |
| 14 | captions-001 | not-an-assertion | — | A figure title. | b5ebcada | — | — |
| 15 | captions-033 | not-an-assertion | — | A pointer to Appendix 1—table 4 rather than a result stated in the caption. | 432db563 | — | — |
| 16 | captions-036 | not-an-assertion | — | A pointer to Appendix 1—table 6 rather than a result stated in the caption. | 63d30cde | — | — |
| 17 | captions-045 | not-an-assertion | — | Explains what dots, markers and error bars encode; a graphical-encoding note, not a finding. | 3985fd4e | — | — |
| 18 | captions-046 | covered | left-ifg-cluster-showed-opposite | The STS-seed to left-IFG connectivity with the opposite pattern that did not survive correction is exactly what the claim records. | 50a6749a | 88a2ee04 | — |
| 19 | tables-002 | not-an-assertion | — | Raw model-fit rows (R2, BIC, AIC) and a software list; the model comparison they support is stated as its own claims. | 54cdd22e | — | — |
| 20 | tables-008 | not-an-assertion | — | Raw cluster coordinates for the Risky>safe and Social>Solo decision-phase contrasts the tree already carries. | 241ffdf7 | — | — |
| 21 | tables-016 | gap | — | This LMM row is the only place the decision-phase Risky−Safe Social-versus-Solo coefficients per ROI are reported; no claim carries them beyond precuneus/TPJ. | a4884d7f | — | 77dc607a |
| 22 | tables-019 | gap | — | This LMM row is the only place the decision-phase Risky−Safe Social-versus-Partner coefficients per ROI are reported; no claim carries them beyond precuneus/TPJ. | 70a1fe46 | — | 77dc607a |
| 23 | tables-022 | not-an-assertion | — | Raw cluster coordinates for the risky-versus-safe outcome-phase contrast the tree already carries. | f300c978 | — | — |
| 24 | tables-031 | gap | — | Alongside the claimed insula effect, this row is the only place the right middle-temporal response to low partner outcomes (Social>Partner) is reported. | 76a9fec8 | — | 77dc607a |
| 25 | tables-032 | gap | — | This row is the only place the right middle-temporal low-minus-high outcome difference (Social>Partner) is reported; no claim carries it. | 2060caf1 | — | 77dc607a |
How it is defined
A model answers this layer, so the prompt is the layer. It is reproduced below from the committed file, and it is a declared input — editing it makes every run that used it stale.
The declaration names this path and the repository does not have it. An input that does not exist hashes to nothing, so it cannot make a run stale — the layer is declared to depend on something it is not in fact tracking.
The declaration names this path and the repository does not have it. An input that does not exist hashes to nothing, so it cannot make a run stale — the layer is declared to depend on something it is not in fact tracking.
Artifacts
Versions
From the run ledger. There is no changelog beside it to keep in step.
-
v4 · 2026-09-12 · Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) (subagent, via --answer)
adjudication re-run post-stance (#96)
python3 scripts/adjudicate.py gadeke-2026-guilt-insula --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.json --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.v4.json
-
v3 · 2026-09-12 · Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) (subagent, via --answer)
adjudication under the current chain (#96)
python3 scripts/adjudicate.py gadeke-2026-guilt-insula --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.json --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.v3.json
-
v2 · 2026-09-11 · supplied:runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.json
re-adjudicated against the current claim tree; the 2026-09-09 verdicts were hand-written against a tree that no longer exists
python3 scripts/adjudicate.py gadeke-2026-guilt-insula --answer runs/gadeke-2026-guilt-insula/adjudication.answer.json
-
v1 · 2026-09-09 · unrecorded backfilled from the artifact
backfilled from the artifact on disk
This layer across the corpus
Across the corpus
10 stale·a paper links to its own cell, where this layer's output for it is rendered
Inputs and outputs
- Reads, besides its dependencies
-
- extract/prompts/coverage-adjudicator.md · declared, and not in the repository — it hashes to nothing, so it cannot make a run stale
- scripts/adjudicate.py · declared, and not in the repository — it hashes to nothing, so it cannot make a run stale
- Produces
-
- mappings/{paper}.json
One per paper — the table above links each one that exists.
- Views
-
- table — rendered above, over the 121 spans in the artifact
Running it
The command comes from the declaration, so this text and what actually runs cannot
diverge. pipeline.py run also runs the unmet dependencies first.
python3 scripts/pipeline.py run <paper> adjudication
Underneath, that runs python3 scripts/adjudicate.py {paper} --answer runs/{paper}/adjudication.answer.json.